Melbourne vs Sydney Archives - Waking up in Geelong https://wongm.com/tag/melbourne-vs-sydney/ Marcus Wong. Gunzel. Engineering geek. History nerd. Tue, 09 Jan 2024 05:19:31 +0000 en-AU hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.7.1 23299142 Farewell to Melbourne’s first electric bus https://wongm.com/2024/01/farewell-transdev-melbourne-first-electric-bus/ https://wongm.com/2024/01/farewell-transdev-melbourne-first-electric-bus/#comments Mon, 08 Jan 2024 20:30:00 +0000 https://wongm.com/?p=21733 This is the story of Melbourne’s first electric bus, which doesn’t even operate in Victoria any more. The story starts in 2019, when Melbourne-based bus body builder Volgren was building a prototype electric bus on an imported BYD K9 chassis. In July 2019 Volgren completed the prototype of its first ever pure-electric bus, a product […]

The post Farewell to Melbourne’s first electric bus appeared first on Waking up in Geelong.

Post retrieved by 35.215.163.46 using

]]>
This is the story of Melbourne’s first electric bus, which doesn’t even operate in Victoria any more.

Transdev electric bus #3000 BS05MR on route 903 at Sunshine station

The story starts in 2019, when Melbourne-based bus body builder Volgren was building a prototype electric bus on an imported BYD K9 chassis.

In July 2019 Volgren completed the prototype of its first ever pure-electric bus, a product launch the company is describing as its most significant since it introduced the Optimus route bus in 2013.

The 12.2-metre vehicle is built on a BYD K9 electric bus chassis and features 324-kilowatt hours of battery capacity. It’s capable of travelling up to 300 kilometres on a single charge and will carry a total of 61 passengers; 39 seats and 22 standees, the company states.

Volgren has been investigating electric technology for more than five years and the prototype alone has involved 12 months of planning, research and engineering problem-solving, as well as partnership-building and discussion with BYD – not to mention the build itself.

There is a great deal of pride at Volgren that its first pure-electric vehicle body was not a brand new design, but a modified Optimus.

That’s not to say, however, that this project was merely a matter of Volgren placing its flagship product over BYD’s and getting the wiring right. Kearney explains that the electric vehicle body Volgren developed required a number of new parts, among them “…new moulded solutions for interior finish and fitout”, as well as “…the introduction of a roof-treatment package designed to better integrate the roof-mounted EV equipment into the vehicle”.

To understand how Volgren ensured these components – and the bus as a whole – worked precisely as it needed to, it’s best to go back to 2018.

“We began with some feasibility studies and reviews in early 2018, assessing the product layout, compliance with Australian Design Rules and other regulations, suitability for Australian customer specification and developing a preliminary understanding of the high-voltage systems and their integration,” Kearney said.

In June of that year the company sent two design engineers to China to attend ‘familiarisation training’ with BYD.

“This process also included a review of issues elicited through the feasibility study and the provision of design and product information from BYD to enable commencement of detailed design.”

Kearney says that for assistance with development of the aesthetic roof treatment they turned to Monash University’s Mobility Design Lab. It was a partnership Volgren knew it could count on, having worked with Monash University in the development of the Optimus Route Bus body earlier this decade.

A few months later the Victorian Government announcing an electric bus trial in conjunction with bus operator Transdev Melbourne.

Victoria’s first locally built, fully electric bus will soon begin carrying passengers on one of Melbourne’s busiest routes, thanks to a partnership between the Andrews Labor Government and Transdev.

The bus will run on Route 246 between Elsternwick and Clifton Hill via St Kilda before potentially being used across other inner Melbourne routes.

The body construction and fit out for the new bus was carried out in Dandenong by Volgren, supporting Victorian jobs and backing the local automotive industry to develop new capability and innovation.

The new zero-emission bus is fitted with 324 kWH of Lithium Phosphate batteries providing 300 kilometers of travel range.

The bus will be based at Transdev’s North Fitzroy depot where a charging station has been installed.

The trial will continue until January 2021 and will be reviewed to determine the potential to roll out fully electric buses across Victoria.

However the trial was the idea of Transdev Australasia and not the Victorian Government, as part of what they called ‘Project Aurora

The seeds for the company’s zero-emissions ambitions ‘Down Under’ were sown in 2019, following a phone call with Transdev Australasia’s chief engineer Marc Cleave and Volgren Australia.

Dandenong-based Volgren had recently commenced manufacture of its BYD-chassis prototype electric bus – a modified version of its popular Optimus model. For Transdev and Marc Cleave, now somewhat a veteran of the bus manufacturing scene, the call helped to ignite a vision for a zero-emissions fleet in Australia and New Zealand, helping to kick-start internal ‘Project Aurora’.

Transdev had pioneered zero-emissions electric and hydrogen fleets internationally, it says, but usage in the Australian and New Zealand market was still in relative infancy. From our international learnings we knew the value that zero emissions vehicles could add to our local fleets and contracts, which is why we acted quickly in developing Project Aurora.”

Armed with insights about what worked, Transdev quickly set about gathering a group of locally based suppliers to help realise the vision and bring the company’s first electric bus – ‘Aurora 1’ – to Melbourne in November, 2019.

Under Project Aurora, Transdev took delivery of its first new Volgren BYD Optimus electric bus and BYD charging infrastructure in November, 2019, with the bus going into service on Melbourne’s streets in December of that year, as part of a trial with Victoria’s Department of Transport.

The remaining four vehicles rolled off Volgren’s Dandenong production line in March, 2021, with one commencing service in Brisbane in April and three going into service in Sydney in May. Gala events were held in Dandenong, Brisbane and Sydney, with local authorities, stakeholders and industry to celebrate the launch of the new fleet.

Tessari says the commissioning of the Transdev fleet as part of Project Aurora was significant for the company.

Transdev Australasia funded three of the five vehicles delivered under Project Aurora. Transport for NSW directly funded two vehicles for Sydney, which Transdev procured on its behalf.

“We wanted to demonstrate zero-emissions technology by investing our own cash in it. It’s here now, and it’s the future now that we want to promote to government and show that public transport can be decarbonised,” Craig added.

The trial bus was given fleet number #3000 and registration plate BS05MR, with the first stage of the trial program commencing in December 2019 on route 246, followed by stage two in October 2020 on route 250, and stage three in May 2021 on route 903.

Transdev electric bus #3000 BS05MR on route 251 along Rathdowne Street, Carlton North

November 2021 also saw the electric bus receive special ‘Ride with Pride’ decals on the side.

Transdev electric bus #3000 BS05MR on route 903 at Wright Street and Hampshire Road, Sunshine

But then bad news for Transdev Melbourne – in October 2021 it was announced that their bid for an extension of their Melbourne Bus Franchise contract had failed, and that a new operator would take over – Kinetic, parent company of Melbourne’s SkyBus service.

As a result, once the electric bus trial ended in October 2021, Transdev Melbourne withdrew the bus from their fleet, and sent up to Transdev NSW to join their fleet of four other electric buses operating in Sydney.


Video by NSW Transport on YouTube

Where it also lived a short life, being withdrawn from service in July 2023 and placed into storage.

The only consolation prize for Melbourne – Transdev’s successor Kinetic has to introduce 36 electric buses to their fleet by mid-2025.

Kinetic electric bus #3017 BS10SA at Queen and Bourke Street

Transit Systems in Melbourne’s west also purchasing electric buses.

Transit Systems electric bus #166 BS09LM on route 420 at Sunshine station

Along with Sunbury Bus Service.

Sunbury Bus Service electric bus #106 3106AO on route 481 at Sunbury station

Ventura in Melbourne’s east.

Ventura electric bus #1620 BS10ZB on a route 109 cruise shuttle at Market and Flinders Street

And Mitchell Transit in Seymour.

Mitchell Transit electric bus #72 BS07LF on High Street, Seymour

But not much of an improvement over the massive order for 50 hybrid buses CDC Melbourne made back in 2019.


CDC Melbourne photo

Footnote: the gory details

History of Transdev’s trial electric bus #3000 from Australian Bus Fleet Lists:

Chassis Type:
BYD D9RA

Chassis No:
LC04S44S4J1000003

Body Manufacturer:
Volgren Optimus

Body No:
VG4899

Body Date:
9/19

Registered BS05MR:
16/12/2021

Transferred to Transdev NSW, and registered as m/o 8190:
24/04/2022

Withdrawn by 29/7/23 and placed in storage

Post retrieved by 35.215.163.46 using

The post Farewell to Melbourne’s first electric bus appeared first on Waking up in Geelong.

]]>
https://wongm.com/2024/01/farewell-transdev-melbourne-first-electric-bus/feed/ 18 21733
Interstate mix and match from mX https://wongm.com/2015/05/mx-newspaper-localised-content/ https://wongm.com/2015/05/mx-newspaper-localised-content/#comments Thu, 28 May 2015 21:30:24 +0000 http://wongm.com/?p=6067 In May 2015 publisher News Corp decided to shut down the free ‘mX’ newspaper after years of falling circulation. Targeted at commuters in Melbourne, Sydney and Brisbane – the newspaper had for years had saved money by sharing content between the three markets, with only slight modifications appearing in each local edition.

Handing out copies of mX to afternoon commuters at Footscray station

The post Interstate mix and match from mX appeared first on Waking up in Geelong.

Post retrieved by 35.215.163.46 using

]]>
In May 2015 publisher News Corp decided to shut down the free ‘mX’ newspaper after years of falling circulation. Targeted at commuters in Melbourne, Sydney and Brisbane – the newspaper had for years had saved money by sharing content between the three markets, with only slight modifications appearing in each local edition.

Handing out copies of mX to afternoon commuters at Footscray station

The letters page was the most common place to find city-specific references – you’ll only find V/Line in Victoria.

Captain Obvious - "Was the V/Line train late?"

You won’t find myki outside of Melbourne either.

"Looking for a girl with Myki trouble" - you need to be a bit more specific!

This side by side comparison of the Melbourne and Sydney editions of mX illustrates the slight page layout changes that result from the different selection of letters per edition.

Melbourne vs. Sydney - two editions of mX

On occasion the reuse of content in mX also stretched to the graphics – this photoshopped train had “Flinders Street” text added in the Melbourne edition, but “Wynyard” in the Sydney edition.

Copy and paste between mX editions

Plus the photo is of a Melbourne train.

At times ambiguous locations tripped up the editor – there are ‘Central’ stations in both Sydney and Brisbane, as well as a ‘Melbourne Central’ station down south.

Which 'Central' station did they see the hottie at?

Both Melbourne and Sydney have a suburb called Epping with a railway station, but only one city has a ‘M54’ bus route serving it.

All aboard the M54 bus from Epping station

Route M54 is a ‘Metrobus’ route operated by Sydney Buses

There isn’t a Meadowbank in Victoria, so this letter in the Melbourne edition was another slipup.

'Meadowbank' isn't a station in Melbourne!

Occasionally the news section would also trip up on a state-specifc reference – this article about scholarships from the NSW based ‘Universities Admissions Centre‘ is of little use to a Victorian.

Article from the Sydney edition accidentally included in the Melbourne version

Until the 2015 relaunch of mX, the front page of each issue featured a city-specifc weather report. On at least one occasion, the Melbourne edition received a much more sunnier forecast than usual.

Mixup at the layout stage - Brisbane weather report in the Melbourne edition

In this case, the forecast was for Brisbane

And finally – the advertisements. Selling ad space in the newspaper was the only way that News Corp made any money out of mX, so there were plenty of them – often city specific.

PTV was a big spender, given the target market of mX being an exact match for their service update notifications.

PTV finally run advertisements advising of that route 75 trams no longer use Spencer Street

But occasionally advertisements from interstate slipped through the cracks, such as this one for a Sydney fun run.

Sydney fun run advertised in the Melbourne issue of mX

I’m not sure how many 9 to 5 commuters in Melbourne are available at 1pm on a Friday to compete in a fun run located 800-odd kilometres away!

Post retrieved by 35.215.163.46 using

The post Interstate mix and match from mX appeared first on Waking up in Geelong.

]]>
https://wongm.com/2015/05/mx-newspaper-localised-content/feed/ 4 6067